Argyris’s Theory – A Roadmap to Human Motivation

The ever-intriguing Argyris’s Theory has long been a source of deep thought and study across a variety of disciplines. Argyris’ Theory is reflective of the late Chris Argyris. He was a Harvard professor who focused on organizational behavior and management theory. He focused on understanding why some organizations succeed while others fail. It was through this study that he came up with his comprehensive theory of human motivation.

Argyris's Theory of Motivation

Chris Argyris’s theory of motivation is a powerful tool for understanding the internal dynamics of motivation within an organization. Its focus is on internal psychological processes and the structure of organizational systems. It provides a unique perspective on how behavior is shaped, and how human resources can be best utilized.

Applying Argyris’s theory to the workplace can help organizations to better understand both their employees and their environment. It can also enable them to effectively motivate behavior and promote workplace satisfaction. This theory is of particular relevance to the study of human behavior and can feel overwhelming to grasp. We can then better explore its implications for our everyday lives.

What is Argyris’s Theory?

Chris Argyris offers us a more sophisticated view of McGregor’s Theory X and Theory Y models of motivation. His conclusion is that we need to treat people as adults.

Argyris put forward his ‘Immaturity-Maturity Theory’. This suggested that if you treat people like children, you motivate the wrong behaviors. According to this theory, the development of a person goes from a situation of immaturity to a situation of maturity. A mature person is characterized by being active, independent, self-confident, and self-controlled. On the contrary, an immature person is passive, dependent, lacking confidence, and feeling to be controlled by others.

1. Introduction

From an organizational point of view, Agryis believed that managers who treat people positively and who are responsible adults will achieve the highest productivity. He thought that the common problems of employees avoiding work, showing lack of interest, and low morale, may be signs of a mismatch between managerial practice and the mature adult personality. 

His solution to the problem is to broaden job responsibilities, allow for more variety of tasks, and adjust supervisory styles to allow greater participation and promote better human relationships. Organizations often expect their cooperators to be passive, dependent, have a short-term perspective, and produce without requiring a high level of control. According to Argyris, when an employee with a high level of maturity is before a situation like this, they tend to adopt one of three attitudes:

  • Escape: It is reflected in resignation, absenteeism, etc …
  • Fight: Through structures such as trade unions or even through an informal organization;
  • Adaptation: This is the most common reaction and consists of developing an attitude of apathy and indifference, in which the monthly salary represents compensation for the “punishment.”

2. Theory

Chris Argyris viewed upon the relationship and tension between people’s needs and the needs of their organization. His theory states that personality evolves from Immaturity to Maturity, across a continuum. And this ‘Immaturity-Maturity Theory’ suggests that employee apathy arises when managers treat employees like children. And if they do so because of organizational constraints, there is a conflict (or tension) between people’s needs and those of the organization.

We can represent the Immaturity-Maturity continuum as a series of endpoints:

If organizational controls impose passivity, dependence, and subordination, it will favor immaturity. This will bring out either:

  • More immaturity behaviors in less mature individuals
  • Frustration and compensating behaviors in more mature individuals.
  • They will create internal networks that work against the imposed hierarchy.

Therefore, what we need to do as managers and leaders is:

  • Align organizational and individual goals
  • Treat people as equals
  • Allow them independence, autonomy, and agency
  • Encourage the development of skills and knowledge

4. Key Concepts

Understand Argyris Theory to unlock your potential. This powerful concept focuses on leveraging strengths and weaknesses to optimize short and long-term potential. Embrace your gifts and identify areas of improvement to achieve success.

Self-regulation is key, as it enables you to control your behavior and emotions to reach your objectives. By grasping the fundamentals of Argyris’s Theory, you can make the most of your abilities.

5. Validity

Argyris’s Theory is gaining traction among theorists and researchers looking to comprehend human behavior. This theory could offer many perks. One of the most prominent is its ability to probe how people interact with their social environment.

By studying how individuals experience their surroundings, Argyris’s Theory can detect potential sources of tension, irritation, or discord. It can aid in crafting suitable strategies to tackle them. This could be especially beneficial in corporate settings where effective team dynamics are crucial for success.

6. Challenges

Argyriss’s Theory presents a host of challenges. These are for both, those attempting to comprehend it, and those hoping to effectively utilize its principles. It is complex, with intricate layers requiring extensive research and examination to fully understand. Applying it, in reality, can prove tricky, as it necessitates an in-depth knowledge of the particular context to gain an accurate insight into its implications.

Furthermore, Argyris’s Theory may necessitate a reframing of existing paradigms and approaches. It poses a challenge to the status quo and requires a shift in thought. Despite its difficulties, this theory is worth exploring. It can provide invaluable insights into how to better manage and interact with the natural environment.

7. Conclusion

To maximize Argyris’s Theory’s potential, it’s essential to understand its components. Unpacking the theory and delving into its implications can help us gain insight into how it works and how to apply it.

With the right approach, Argyris’s Theory can be a powerful tool for positive change. However, it’s important to remember that understanding its components is just the start. Appreciating its nuances and ramifications requires continuous exploration.

Wrap Up

Argyris’s Theory is a crucial step in understanding the behaviors of organizations and individuals. It can help us understand how their choices can affect their environment. It can lead to a deeper understanding of how employees can become more productive, and how the organization as a whole can become more successful.

This is a deep and complex topic. Argyris’s Theory provides a useful framework for exploring the intricacies of human behavior and organizational structure. Ultimately, it provides insight into how our choices and actions shape our lives and determine our success.

Image by Freepik

  • uhayat
  • The author has rich management exposure in banking, textiles, and teaching in business administration.